Disclaimer

Disclaimer: I am providing the content on this blog solely for the reader's general information. This blog contains my personal commentary on issues that interest me. Unless otherwise stated, the views expressed on this blog are mine alone, and not the views of any law firm with which I am in any way associated or any other member of any such law firm. Nothing on this blog is intended to be a solicitation of, or the provision of, legal advice, nor to create an attorney-client relationship with me or any law firm. Please view my "Full Disclaimer" statement at the bottom of the page for additonal information..

Wednesday, September 18, 2013

New Book Revisits Matthew Shepard Case: Gay Wyoming Man Brutally Murdered in 1998



Matthew Shepard was a young gay man brutally murdered while tied to a fence post in Wyoming on October 6, 1998.  His murder spurred outrage and fierce protests, and was the impetus (along with the James Byrd dragging murder in East Texas) for both the Federal Hate Crimes Prevention Act, and in Shepard’s case, President Obama’s professed passion about LBGT equality.  Now a new book by journalist Stephen Jimenez, himself gay, titled The Book of Matt: Hidden Truths about the Murder of Matthew Shepard, calls into question the central ethos of the case. 


The case played out as one of a homophobic hate crime.  What didn’t come out much in the media was that the Aaron McKinney, one of the attackers was also gay, or at least bisexual, and had a sexual relationship with Shepard.  Jimenez’s book does not attempt to change the fact that Shepard was horribly murdered, but, as the Advocate puts it, “may change how we interpret the murder.”

The Book of Matt looks at the culture of meth in Wyoming and its brutal consequences. The Advocate says:

“By several accounts, McKinney had been on a meth bender for five days prior to the murder, and spent much of October 6 trying to find more drugs. By the evening he was so wound up that he attacked three other men in addition to Shepard. Even Cal Rerucha, the prosecutor who had pushed for the death sentence for McKinney and Henderson, would later concede on ABC’s 20/20 that “it was a murder that was driven by drugs.”

No one was talking much about meth abuse in 1998, though it was rapidly establishing itself in small-town America, as well as in metropolitan gay clubs, where it would leave a catastrophic legacy. In Wyoming in the late 1990s, eighth graders were using meth at a higher rate than 12th graders nationwide. It’s hardly surprising to learn from Jimenez that Shepard was also a routine drug user, and — according to some of his friends — an experienced dealer. (Although there is no real evidence for supposing that Shepard was using drugs himself on the night of his murder).”



The Advocate also points out that a former lover of Shepard confirmed that Shepard and McKinney had sex while doing drugs in the back of a limo. The manager of a Denver gay bar recounted his shock at realizing that “these guys who killed that kid came from inside our own community.”

A fact pointed to by both the book and the article in the Advocate is the force with which Shepard was murdered, having a gun barrel slammed into his head so violently as to crush his brain stem.  It could be that this was a hate crime, or a drug crime, or both. The book promises to get into the facts and elucidate them as much as can be done in a crime so brutal and full of complexity.

The Book of Matt: Hidden Truths about the Murder of Matthew Shepard (Steerforth Press) is due out October 1 and looks to be well worth the read.

No comments:

Post a Comment